Reporting from Los Angeles for UK’s Precision Marketing magazine
25th March, 1996.
What practical advantage is there to internet marketing
and does it attract a different sort of customer?
Ray Hanks explores the new media promise
from the US DMA Conference in LA,
a week before the Oscars.
When the direct marketers of America gathered in Los Angeles a week ago for their Spring Conference,
expectations were high because the intended destination for most of them was the brave new world of
Cyberspace. Interactive technology, we are told, is here to stay and the information revolution has
irrevocably changed marketing life as we know it. With 9.5 million Internet users already, the prospect is
irrestistible. Or is it?
A striking mix of hi-tech presentation and typical American panache kept the myth or magic show teasingly
alive for three days. Running alongside the traditional conference pillars of database marketing and
customer loyalty programmes, the complex interactive itinerary provided the US DMA team from New York
with a Herculean task. The resulting five-track lecture schedule was slick and impressive but quickly
revealed the mother of all dillemmas. We’re all excited about the new media, but what are we supposed to
do about it?
We might undesrstandably gasp at the frightening statistic from
service provider America-On-Line that it is signing up 300,000
new customers every month. But before you can catch your breath,
consider the reality that 77 per cent of all Web users never make a
purchase. Surfing without sales? Technology that allows prospects
to ‘interact’ offers a garguantuan choice when searching for
information but, if it fails to induce an action to buy, the potential
for direct marketers is dramaticaly weakened.
In the opening key note speech, Vivid Studios interactive creative
director, Nathan Shedroff admitted that there are very few good
selling sites on the Web. Worse still was his confession that he’d
never actually purchased anything himself, despite spending much
of his working life on the Net. “Think of the Web as a new telephone
system,” Shedroff pleaded. “That’s where we’re at with the Web at
the moment, although too many people have just stopped at the
information level.”
“The technology itself is not important, it’s the whole communication experience that matters and we’ve all
got to work harder to turn it into a selling experience.”
Reassuringly, some already have. Department store group JC Penney have selected 500 products to actively
market on the Internet and it plans to expand this to 1,500 during 1996.
Convenience is the key attraction for many customers who purchase products not actively marketed,
selecting them from the company catalogue but preferring this quick and hassle free method of placing the
order.
But - and this is the bit that gets real direct marketers double clicking on their collective mouse - nearly half
of JC Penney’s on-line customers are new, never having set foot in one of its stores or opened the pages of a
catalogue before.
So are these new sales customers switching from other stores or was this genuinely incremental business
created by the new media? JC Penney electronic retailing manager, Marisha Konkowski has no doubts. She
says: “The profiles of these people are so different from the norm that we really do believe that these
purchases wouldn’t otherwise have been made.”
Once upon a time, JC Penney might also have defined its target audience in terms of the catchment areas of
each of its stores. Now with the Internet giving it access to customers in 150 countries, its virtual catchment
starts to defy all previous rules of geography.
New expanded markets? New marketing opportunities? Perhaps that’s why 2,000 profit-motivated delegates
descended on LA.
So if JC Penney can do it, what’s happening to the wannabees? Is there a problem with interactive
technology when it involves taking money? Is it something to do with the rumours about the security of
credit card details being used to make purchases on the Internet? “Unfair,” claims CompuServe manager
Keith Arnold. “As far as I know, there have been no recorded instances of credit card numbers being stolen.”
“Well, there was one,” says David Edwards, director of business development at New York firm Evergreen
Internet, “but it took two students at Berkeley using $10m worth of kit to grab the details for one single card.
The industry got a lot of bad press for that, which seems grossly unfair.”
Edwards went on to explain, however, that there was an illicit acticity called packet sniffing (don’t ask) where
no less than 10,000 credit cards had been spirited away on the the Net’s ether. “Okay, okay, so that bad
press probably was deserved,” he reluctantly agrees.
So, does interecative technology genuinely provide us with a new communications Utopia? Or has showbiz
mania moved into town a week early? The truth is probably best summed up by Jon Alcorn, interactive
services director, at Internet specialists CUC International.
“Maybe we’re all basking in the unreal light of a false dawn,” he suggests. “The whole industry - including Bill
Gates - has been blindsided by the speed at which the Web has spread. But when we’ve done a little
catching up, this revolution will be for real.”
With the number of Net users forecast to reach a staggering 200 million* by the turn of the century, any
marketer ignoring the new technologies risks being left behind and lost in Cyberspace.
Ray Hanks - March 1996, Los Angeles.
* Author’s Note: Latest estimate for worldwide internet users is over 1.8 billion.
“Maybe we’re basking
in the unreal light of a
false dawn...but when
we’ve done catching
up, the revolution will
be for real”
Jon Alcorn, CUC
International
Website design by The House of Elliott
Principal photography by James Nader